Add the tequila, Cointreau, and lime juice to a cocktail shaker — no ice yet. Ice added early just waters down the flavors while you work.
Rim a wine glass (yes, a wine glass — tequila is the wine of Mexico) with a squeezed lime half, then dip it lightly in salt — or in Tajín, which we use just as often. A partial rim is fine; keep the glass upright afterward so the rim doesn't fall into the drink.
Fill the glass with fresh ice.
Now add a good scoop of ice to the shaker, seal it, and shake hard until the shaker is properly cold — until your hands are really too cold. Forget counting shakes or seconds; cold is the signal.
Strain into the prepared glass, leaving the shaker ice behind. If you're making two, pour back and forth between the glasses so they're balanced.